Interactive visualizations of high-dimensional data using J3

Project Platypus is a repository that supports multiple Python libraries for multi-objective optimization, scenario discovery, and data analysis. Past blogposts have already demonstrated the Rhodium [1, 2] and Platypus [3] libraries. The aim of this post is to demonstrate the capabilities of J3 and its implementation within Project Platypus, through the Python module J3Py. J3 is an open source, cross-platform Java application for producing and sharing high-dimensional, interactive scientific visualizations. It can be used within Project Platypus, through J3Py, which is a Python module that allows us to call J3 within Python scripts. This blogpost will look into a simple system I’ve been working on and use the Rhodium library to generate management alternatives. I’ll then show how J3 can be used to explore the tradeoffs in the alternatives generated and aid in the negotiated selection of alternatives.

First thing to do is load the necessary libraries:

import numpy as np # This is a library required by the model
import itertools # This is a library required by the model
from rhodium import * # This is the library needed to use Rhodium
from j3 import J3 # This is the library we'll be using to visualize solutions

We then need to define the model function, it’s a bit long and not immediately pertinent to the blogpost so I’ll put it at the bottom so readers don’t have to scroll through it. The optimization will be performed using Rhodium and it’s set up like so:

model = Model(fish_game)

model.parameters = [Parameter("vars"),

model.responses = [Response("NPV", Response.MAXIMIZE),
                   Response("PreyDeficit", Response.MINIMIZE),
                   Response("ConsLowHarvest", Response.MINIMIZE),
                   Response("WorstHarvest", Response.MAXIMIZE),
                   Response("PredatorExtinction", Response.INFO)]

model.constraints = [Constraint("PredatorExtinction < 1")]

model.levers = [RealLever("vars", 0.0, 1.0, length = 6)]

output = optimize(model, "NSGAII", 1000)

As Julie has covered Rhodium already, I won’t go into the details here, but it’s pretty intuitive that we first declare what the model is, input parameters, responses (i.e. objectives and constraints), and decision variables. Instead, I’ll focus on analyzing the output (the candidate solutions found) using J3. “output” here is a “DataSet” object of the Rhodium module and contains the decision variables, and objective performance of the solutions identified. There is also a constraint (“PredatorExtinction”) which is always zero in all the solutions, and I will not be visualizing here. I will not edit or change anything on my screen before screen-grabbing, to demonstrate how truly simple and easy it is to use. To call the J3 environment run:

J3(output.as_dataframe(['NPV', 'PreyDeficit', 'ConsLowHarvest', 'WorstHarvest']))

This produces a window with a 3D scatterplot of three of our objectives in the x, y, and z axes and the fourth used as the color.

Full resolution here

I’d like to start examining what my results look like so I’ll make this larger and rotate it a bit.

Full resolution here

I’d like to also change how my objectives are displayed. So I’ll change the orientation of the axes and the objective used for the color.

Full resolution here

The rainbow color-scheme is not really my aesthetic, so let’s change that also.

Full resolution here

A couple things we can see from this plot: there is a strong tradeoff between the NPV objective and the prey deficit, as well as between the prey deficit and the Worst Harvest. We can examine these pairs of tradeoffs more explicitly, by pulling the axes’ planes out and projecting the values on the 2D surfaces:

Full resolution here

We can also examine the tradeoffs using a parallel axis plot:

Full resolution here

We can also move the axes in the parallel axis plot:

Full resolution here

Having these multiple views, we can highlight and examine particular solutions and see how they compare with others, as well as get more detailed information:

Full resolution here and here

The final feature I’d like to showcase is solution brushing, which can facilitate in the negotiation of solutions process. Brushing allows decision makers to set limits on what the believe is acceptable or unacceptable performance (e.g. “I cannot accept costs above X amount”). It also allows decision makers to more closely examine where potential tensions might arise. If, for example, one negotiating party sets their bar too high, all remaining solutions might be unacceptable by the other decision making parties. Tools like brushing make this process more transparent and straightforward.

Full resolution here

The model function used in the example is posted below. I would also like to mention ScreenToGif, which is the tool I used to produce these GIFs and it’s been super easy to download and start using. Great product.

nRBF = 2 # no. of RBFs to use
nIn = 1 # no. of inputs (depending on selected strategy)
nOut = 1 # no. of outputs (depending on selected strategy)

N = 100 # Number of realizations of environmental stochasticity

tSteps = 100 # no. of timesteps to run the fish game on

# Define problem to be solved
def fish_game(vars, # contains all C, R, W for RBF policy
              a = 0.005, # rate at which the prey is available to the predator
              b = 0.5, # prey growth rate
              c = 0.5, # rate with which consumed prey is converted to predator abundance
              d = 0.1, # predator death rate
              h = 0.1, # handling time (time each predator needs to consume the caught prey)
              K = 2000, # prey carrying capacity given its environmental conditions
              m = 0.7, # predator interference parameter
              sigmaX = 0.004, # variance of stochastic noise in prey population
              sigmaY = 0.004): # variance of stochastic noise of predator population

    x = np.zeros(tSteps+1) # Create prey population array
    y = np.zeros(tSteps+1) # Create predator population array
    z = np.zeros(tSteps+1) # Create harvest array

    # Create array to store harvest for all realizations
    harvest = np.zeros([N,tSteps+1])
    # Create array to store effort for all realizations
    effort = np.zeros([N,tSteps+1])
    # Create array to store prey for all realizations
    prey = np.zeros([N,tSteps+1])
    # Create array to store predator for all realizations
    predator = np.zeros([N,tSteps+1])
    # Create array to store metrics per realization
    NPV = np.zeros(N)
    cons_low_harv = np.zeros(N)
    harv_1st_pc = np.zeros(N)    
    # Create array with environmental stochasticity for prey
    epsilon_prey = np.random.normal(0.0, sigmaX, N)
    # Create array with environmental stochasticity for predator
    epsilon_predator = np.random.normal(0.0, sigmaY, N)
    #Set policy input and output ranges
    input_ranges = [[0, K]] # Prey pop. range to use for normalization
    output_ranges = [[0, 1]] # Range to de-normalize harvest to

    # Go through N possible realizations
    for i in range(N):
        # Initialize populations and values
        x[0] = prey[i,0] = K
        y[0] = predator[i,0] = 250
        z[0] = effort[i,0] = hrvSTR([x[0]], vars, input_ranges, output_ranges)
        NPVharvest = harvest[i,0] = effort[i,0]*x[0]        
        # Go through all timesteps for prey, predator, and harvest
        for t in range(tSteps):
            if x[t] > 0 and y[t] > 0:
                x[t+1] = (x[t] + b*x[t]*(1-x[t]/K) - (a*x[t]*y[t])/(np.power(y[t],m)+a*h*x[t]) - z[t]*x[t])* np.exp(epsilon_prey[i]) # Prey growth equation
                y[t+1] = (y[t] + c*a*x[t]*y[t]/(np.power(y[t],m)+a*h*x[t]) - d*y[t]) *np.exp(epsilon_predator[i]) # Predator growth equation
                if t <= tSteps-1:
                    z[t+1] = hrvSTR([x[t]], vars, input_ranges, output_ranges)
            prey[i,t+1] = x[t+1]
            predator[i,t+1] = y[t+1]
            effort[i,t+1] = z[t+1]
            harvest[i,t+1] = z[t+1]*x[t+1]
            NPVharvest = NPVharvest + harvest[i,t+1]*(1+0.05)**(-(t+1))
        NPV[i] = NPVharvest
        low_hrv = [harvest[i,j]<prey[i,j]/20 for j in range(len(harvest[i,:]))] # Returns a list of True values when there's harvest below 5%
        count = [ sum( 1 for _ in group ) for key, group in itertools.groupby( low_hrv ) if key ] # Counts groups of True values in a row
        if count: # Checks if theres at least one count (if not, np.max won't work on empty list)
            cons_low_harv[i] = np.max(count)  # Finds the largest number of consecutive low harvests
            cons_low_harv[i] = 0
        harv_1st_pc[i] = np.percentile(harvest[i,:],1)
    return (np.mean(NPV), # Mean NPV for all realizations
            np.mean((K-prey)/K), # Mean prey deficit
            np.mean(cons_low_harv), # Mean worst case of consecutive low harvest across realizations
            np.mean(harv_1st_pc), # 5th percentile of all harvests
            np.mean((predator < 1).sum(axis=1))) # Mean number of predator extinction days per realization

# Calculate outputs (u) corresponding to each sample of inputs
# u is a 2-D matrix with nOut columns (1 for each output)
# and as many rows as there are samples of inputs
def hrvSTR(Inputs, vars, input_ranges, output_ranges):
    # Rearrange decision variables into C, R, and W arrays
    # C and R are nIn x nRBF and W is nOut x nRBF
    # Decision variables are arranged in 'vars' as nRBF consecutive
    # sets of {nIn pairs of {C, R} followed by nOut Ws}
    # E.g. for nRBF = 2, nIn = 3 and nOut = 4:
    # C, R, C, R, C, R, W, W, W, W, C, R, C, R, C, R, W, W, W, W
    C = np.zeros([nIn,nRBF])
    R = np.zeros([nIn,nRBF])
    W = np.zeros([nOut,nRBF])
    for n in range(nRBF):
        for m in range(nIn):
            C[m,n] = vars[(2*nIn+nOut)*n + 2*m]
            R[m,n] = vars[(2*nIn+nOut)*n + 2*m + 1]
        for k in range(nOut):
            W[k,n] = vars[(2*nIn+nOut)*n + 2*nIn + k]

    # Normalize weights to sum to 1 across the RBFs (each row of W should sum to 1)
    totals = np.sum(W,1)
    for k in range(nOut):
        if totals[k] > 0:
            W[k,:] = W[k,:]/totals[k]
    # Normalize inputs
    norm_in = np.zeros(nIn)
    for m in range (nIn):
        norm_in[m] = (Inputs[m]-input_ranges[m][0])/(input_ranges[m][1]-input_ranges[m][0])
    # Create array to store outputs
    u = np.zeros(nOut)
    # Calculate RBFs
    for k in range(nOut):
        for n in range(nRBF):
            BF = 0
            for m in range(nIn):
                if R[m,n] > 10**-6: # set so as to avoid division by 0
                    BF = BF + ((norm_in[m]-C[m,n])/R[m,n])**2
                    BF = BF + ((norm_in[m]-C[m,n])/(10**-6))**2
            u[k] = u[k] + W[k,n]*np.exp(-BF)
    # De-normalize outputs
    norm_u = np.zeros(nOut)
    for k in range(nOut):
        norm_u[k] = output_ranges[k][0] + u[k]*(output_ranges[k][1]-output_ranges[k][0])
    return norm_u